Not only are we seeing changes on the healthcare scene politically these days, educational options for nursing education are evolving as well. The new Doctor of Nursing Practice, or DNP, degree is causing quite a stir among practicing and prospective NPs. How is the DNP different from the traditional nursing doctorate, the PhD? What real world advantages does it have to offer? Lets take a look.
DNP vs PhD
The major difference between the DNP and PhD in nursing is that the PhD is more research oriented while the DNP is geared toward hands-on clinical practice. A PhD qualifies nurses to participate in research studies and publish scholarly work. Nurses holding a PhD are generally involved almost completely in the academic world rather than working directly with patients in the hospital or clinical setting.
Unlike the PhD, the DNP was created as an advanced educational option for students looking to better their skills and knowledge of hands-on patient care. The DNP is a clinical doctorate degree. The goal of the DNP is to create nursing leaders and nurses who are prepared to integrate research into clinical practice. While nurses with a DNP can certainly teach and work in the academic setting, the degree is not as focused on preparing students to work in the academic world.
Comparison of PhD and NP Programs
The content of DNP and PhD programs varies according to the different goals of these two degrees. PhD programs focus on teaching students to generate clinical data and research while DNP programs teach students to translate this research and incorporate it into clinical practice.
A PhD in nursing program requires a dissertation, often includes some teaching requirements and takes about four to five years to complete. PhD programs do not require clinical hours where students provide patient care. DNP programs do not require a dissertation, but rather a capstone project. This project is based on practice; for example students may investigate a certain clinical intervention or modify nursing practice for a specific population. Clinical hours involving patient care are required as part of a DNP program. DNP programs take an average of two to three years to complete.
Should you advance your nursing degree?
If you want to teach and move your career in the direction of academia, a PhD may be a good option for you. Universities are much more likely to hire you as part of their faculty with a PhD in nursing. Also, if research is your passion, a PhD is the way to go.
If you want to work as a nurse practitioner in the traditional sense, diagnosing and treating patients in the clinic or hospital setting, you have the option to work with just an MSN degree or you may progress to the DNP. While there is talk of making the DNP mandatory in the future, this has not yet become a requirement. Nurse practitioners with a DNP degree currently have the same salaries as master’s prepared nurse practitioners and have the same real world job descriptions. If you want the prestige that comes with holding a doctorate or want to integrate teaching or a more academic focus to your career, then consider getting your DNP. If the focus of your career will be diagnosing and treating patients in the clinic or hospital setting, at this point sticking with an MSN will save you time and money.
Will you advance your nursing degree? Which degree will you choose?